NewsLocal NewsInvestigations


When did AZ DOC know of broken cell locks? 'Corrected timeline' released

Posted at 4:50 PM, May 15, 2019

The Arizona Department of Corrections has adjusted the timeline of when it said top officials first learned about cell locking problems inside the Lewis state prison and what they did to try to combat the problem.

A spokesperson now claims the department learned of the locking problems in November 2017 -- six months earlier than before.

Andrew Wilder, an ADC spokesman, sent a “corrected timeline” to the Arizona Mirror earlier this week and later confirmed the new timeline to ABC15.


The new timeline below and other clarifications conflict with statements first provided to ABC15 in the hours before the station broke its investigation on April 25th. Take a look at the ADC's clarifications below:

  • November 2017: ADC becomes aware of what it considers to be a material increase in the incidents of inmate lock tampering and cell door malfunctions in the three close custody (Morey, Buckley, and Rast) units; immediate inspections and repairs commence; initially two officers are tasked with inspecting cell doors for evidence of tampering and/or malfunction and facilitating repairs as incidents arose, and subsequently two additional officers were assigned.
  • January 2018: Inmate lock tampering and cell door malfunction incidents continue to increase; cell door pinning commences and is completed in June 2018. (Note: This revises our previous statement that pinning began May 2018.)
  • January 2019: Inmate lock tampering involving the pinning mechanism continues; cell door padlocking commences and is completed on April 29, 2019.

In addition to changing the dates of officials’ first knowledge and door pinning, the statement also appears to admit for the first time that the cell doors are broken.

The new information cites “cell door malfunctions” as a problem dating back to November 2017.

FULL COVERAGE: ABC15 investigation uncovers broken cell doors at Arizona prison

Before ABC15’s investigation aired, a spokesman said the department blamed the issue squarely on inmate tampering.

“We firmly dispute the contention that doors do not lock at all. Officers assigned to work on the locks indoors report to us that the locks are functional. It's the inmate tampering that causes them to be able to open their doors,” the earlier statement read.

Many officers and inmates told ABC15 that wasn’t true: Inmate tampering of doors was an additional problem on top of cells that didn’t lock.

RELATED: Prison director Charles Ryan faces ABC15’s questions over broken cell doors

Sources also said that cells at Lewis prison have had significant locking problems for at least five years.

A retired deputy warden backed up those claims in an interview earlier this month. Doug Schuster said he reported 25 percent of cell doors in the Morey Unit of Lewis prison had locking problems in monthly inspection records 2013 and 2014.

Officers and union officials believe the department’s initial assertion, that problems were solely due to inmate tampering, was an attempt to place blame on front-line officers for not controlling the tampering rather than admit to a massive institutional and administrative failure.

After ABC15’s report aired, Director Charles Ryan ordered the emergency padlocking of hundreds of cells. The move was in violation of state fire codes.

This week, the department is completing the transfer of about 800 inmates from Lewis to other state prisons, sources said.

After sending ABC15 it’s updated timeline, the department did not respond to follow-up questions asking for documentation and other information to support the new dates.

Contact ABC15 Investigator Dave Biscobing at