Hall of fame vice president of finance and administration Anthony Savicke told The Mercury News images on the plaques are "representations" and never intended to be photographic likenesses.
But on Tuesday, Hall of fame president Kevin O'Brien told USA TODAY that Chastain will soon receive a new plaque. "It was not a good job on the part of the artist. We're going to do a better job this time," he said.
The 49-year-old Chastain is often remembered for ripping off her jersey and showing her sports bra after nailing the game-winning penalty kick for Team USA in the 1999 World Cup. She played on the U.S. Women's National Team from 1988-2004 and was inducted into the National Soccer Hall of Fame in 2017. She has worked as a broadcaster since 2008.