News

Actions

Mesa police: Child rearing argument precedes murder

Posted

An argument over child rearing leads one man to shoot and kill another man in Mesa.

Police report that on April 10 they were called to a home near Country Club Drive and Brown Road for a report of shots being fired. There, police found a man lying on the ground and bleeding from the neck.

A neighbor told police they heard three gunshots, then heard the suspect, 48-year-old Jose Eladio Castro-Valenzuela, say, “That’s what Oscar gets." 

The victim, Oscar Carmona-Pacheco was reportedly on the phone with his brother during the altercation. His brother reported to police that he heard Valenzuela say, "I don't give a  .... who you bring down, I'm going to kill you either way."

Witnesses say Valenzuela is a neighbor and lives in the area. His girlfriend and the victim have a child together, and police say the argument was about the raising of the victim’s child. 

Upon his arrest, Valenzuela allegedly told police that he shot the victim three times with a gun he purchased on the street a few days prior. 

Valenzuela who has been in the country illegally for 20 years, is being held on a $500,000 bond on a charge of second-degree murder.