Scripps News Life


Butterfinger S’mores Pie Combines All Our Favorite Treats

Butterfinger S’mores Pie Combines All Our Favorite Treats
Posted at 4:00 AM, Jul 24, 2020

Sitting by a fire and making s’mores is one of the best summertime activities, but if you don’t have the chance to sit around a campfire this year, we have a unique s’mores recipe you may want to try instead: Butterfinger s’mores pie.

Combining Butterfinger candy with all the ingredients of a s’more, the recipe from Ferrero will result in a pie that tastes like a s’more, but with the added crunch of a peanut buttery Butterfinger.

You’ll need a graham cracker pie crust, chocolate pudding, chocolate syrup, Butterfinger candy, mini marshmallows and Marshmallow Fluff. While the recipe calls for melting your marshmallows over a fire, you can also melt them in a microwave. Check out the full recipe:

Butterfinger S’mores Pie


1 9-inch graham cracker crust pie

2 cups chocolate pudding

1 cup Butterfinger, chopped

¾ cup Marshmallow Fluff

1 cup mini marshmallows

¼ cup chocolate syrup

For topping: 1 cup Butterfinger, chopped


Layer each ingredient into pie crust as follows: chocolate pudding, Butterfinger, marshmallows, marshmallow fluff.

Over a campfire (or in a microwave), melt the marshmallow.

Top with chopped Butterfinger and a drizzle of chocolate syrup.


If you’re not crazy about pie, but you still crave a Butterfingers-related baked treat, check out this gooey Butterfinger cake instead. This one requires yellow cake ingredients, plus condensed milk, caramel sundae topping, whipped topping and Butterfingers.

Butterfinger also has a handful of recipes on their website including cookies, brownies, cupcakes, toffee bark and more.


If you’re more about the s’mores than the Butterfingers, we have plenty of those recipes, too!

How about some peanut butter s’mores cookies or s’mores Rice Krispies treats? You can even make biscuit s’mores or a s’mores pizza. Or, if you’d rather drink your s’mores instead, try this s’mores martini.

To remove all the work from the process altogether, check out Hostess’s s’mores cupcakes filled with toasted marshmallow filling.


Will you be trying this Butterfinger s’more pie or any other s’mores treats this summer?

This story originally appeared on Simplemost. Checkout Simplemost for additional stories.