Is 'hostage' mover bill HB 2145 in jeopardy?

PHOENIX -
Right now you have no protections if a bad moving company decides to charge more than it quoted and hold your things until you pay up.
 
It's a big problem.
 
Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich says his office has received more than 150 complaints from consumers who have fallen victim and hoped House Bill 2145 would help.
 
If passed, the bill would prohibit moving companies from legally being able to hold a customer's goods in order to get them to pay more money.
 
Instead, the billing dispute would have to be settled in court.
 
"We knew that there was a gap in the law we wanted to make it consistent, we mirrored it after some of the landlord tenant provisions," Brnovich said.
 
The bill unanimously passed the House in mid-February.
 
But Brnovich says it's being held up in the Senate. 
 
And he thinks he knows why.
 
"There's no reason for it not to (pass) other than a bunch of lobbyist and their representatives trying to squash consumer protection laws," he said. " There's no reason why this bill should not have a hearing and there's no reason why it should not have a straight up and down vote."
 
No groups are on record with the Legislature as being opposed to the bill.  
 
Officially, the Arizona Trucking Association lists itself as 'neutral' about the bill.  
 
The group did not respond to us in time for our story but its website urges members to ask senators to either oppose or amend the bill. 
 
Saying in part, "ATA is concerned that, as written, will hurt legitimate movers who will have little recourse against customers who refuse to pay for services.ATA agrees with the intent of the bill. We want to eliminate bad movers who undermine the public trust. However, HB2145 has unintended consequences that will seriously jeopardize legitimate moving companies."
 
State Senator Steve Smith of Maricopa chairs the committee that would decide the bills fate.
 
A spokesperson tells me "some stakeholders had questions about it, and he's letting them work it out. I'd expect it on a future committee agenda."
 
Brnovich says the legislation should be a no brainer.
 
"It's as simple as that, you can't hold people's stuff just because you have a dispute with them over the bill," he says.
 
So what do you think?
 
 
Need my help?
 
Call volunteers with the Assistance League of Phoenix at 855-323-1515, email me at Joe@abc15.com or contact me on Facebook or Twitter.
 
 
Print this article Back to Top

What is Let Joe Know?

Let Joe Know protects YOU the consumer. We expose scams and hold businesses accountable for their contracts and agreements. Most important, we share consumer red flags before they hit your wallet!

ABC15's Let Joe Know reports air every weekday during ABC15 News at 6pm and online at abc15.com/LetJoeKnow.

Want to help Let Joe Know? Become a volunteer! Call 1-855-323-1515 and leave your name, number to start helping us help others.

SO YOU WANT TO KNOW: COMMON QUESTIONS, EASY ANSWERS

How do I erase info from electronics?
Where does my charity money really go?
Is that a real check I got in the mail?
Do I need flood insurance; how can I get it? 
What should I do before hiring a contractor? 
What are the best ways to prevent ID theft?
Do I have 3-days to get out of my contract?
Debt collectors harass me! What are my rights?