SB 1070 ruling could come soon

sb1070_20120424071812_JPG

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 06/10/2012

WASHINGTON - The U.S. Supreme Court could rule as early as Monday on Arizona's controversial immigration law: SB 1070. 

The court scheduled a session beginning at 7 a.m. Arizona time which could include its ruling on the Obama administration's challenge to the law.

The justices have indicated a ruling will come down sometime this month.

The administration challenged the law in 2010, and lower courts struck down key provisions of the legislation, including a requirement for local law enforcement to check immigration status of anyone suspected of being in the country illegally. 

That provision, which can only be exercised if a person is stopped for another reason, has ignited a firestorm of controversy.

Opponents charge it will lead to racial profiling, even though the law specifically prohibits officers from using race as a factor in their decision.

The Obama administration challenge argues SB 1070 "pre-empts" federal law, by going beyond the scope of federal immigration law already in effect. 

The bill's chief sponsor, former state senator Russell Pearce, has said the law is designed to mirror federal law.

During arguments before the court in April, justices hammered Obama administration attorney Donald Verrilli with tough questions, and appeared unconvinced of his argument. At one point, Justice Sonia Sotomayor even admonished Verrilli, saying "you're not selling this very well." 

That hard line of questioning has lead a number of court watchers to expect the high court will overturn those lower court rulings, and possibly even allow the law to go into effect in its entirety.

Opponents have said they are already preparing new legal challenges to the law.

New York Senator Charles Schumer indicated he will sponsor legislation making it illegal for states to pass their own immigration laws. State Senator Steve Gallardo is spearheading an effort to overturn the law through a statewide referendum.

The political ramifications are expected to resonate in a presidential election year.

Supporters of SB 1070 have charged the Obama administration brought the challenge to mobilize latino voters, especially in states like Arizona, where Republicans have the most registered voters, but independents and newly registered latino voters could put the state "in play."

If the court lets the lower court rulings stand, or strikes down the law as a whole, political experts predict a backlash against the Obama administration for its refusal to strictly enforce immigration law.

In Arizona, immigration has been a key issue in the U.S. Senate race, with political newcomer Wil Cardon attacking his opponent, six-term congressman Jeff Flake, in a series of TV ads charging Flake is soft on immigration and sided with the Obama administration. Flake has said the U.S. needs to focus on securing the border before making any other changes in immigration policy.

The law may have played a role in the faltering political career of its author, former state senator Russell Pearce. Pearce was ousted from office in a historic recall election last November. Recall organizers labeled it a backlash against his hardline stance on immigration. Pearce is now running for state senate in a different legislative district. 

It is also possible the court could strike down some provisions and leave others in place. 

That split decision could leave both sides declaring victory. The court has yet to issue rulings in two other key cases -- a discrimination case against Wal-Mart, and the challenge to President Obama's healthcare law. 

It's expected the court will rule on those cases before it rules on the Arizona case.

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
advertisement

RIGHT NOW on ABC15.com


  1. VIDEO: Arias goes 1-on-1 with ABC15

    VIDEO: Arias goes 1-on-1 with ABC15

    Arias sat down with ABC15's Amy Murphy Tuesday night, just hours after jurors began deliberating, to speak out about the trial, her feelings about Travis Alexander's death and whether she wants to live or die.

  2. Man tries to abduct teen in Scottsdale

    Man tries to abduct teen in Scottsdale

    Police are investigating after a man tried to abduct a 19-year-old woman in Scottsdale Tuesday night.

  3. DWTS names new 'Dancing' champ

    DWTS names new 'Dancing' champ

    The winner earned two sets of perfect scores Monday night.

  4. Use it? New dangers of Mirena IUD

    Use it? New dangers of Mirena IUD

    Many women are reporting complications to the federal government regarding the Mirena IUD.

  5. FORECAST: Triple digits back soon!

    FORECAST: Triple digits back soon!

    Find out when the 100s come back and if they'll stick around through Memorial Day weekend.

  6. Arias speaks out as jury deliberates

    Arias speaks out as jury deliberates

    Jodi Arias begged jurors Tuesday to give her life in prison, saying she "lacked perspective" when she said she preferred execution to spending the rest of her days in jail. 

  7. Anthony Weiner launches mayoral bid

    Anthony Weiner launches mayoral bid

    The ex-congressman whose career imploded in a rash of raunchy tweets two years ago said in a YouTube video announcement late Tuesday that he's in the New York City mayoral race.

  8. PD: 2 injured in Glendale shooting

    PD: 2 injured in Glendale shooting

    Police say two people were taken to the hospital Tuesday night after a shooting in Glendale.

  9. Foster Farms chicken strips recalled

    Foster Farms chicken strips recalled

    Foster Farms is recalling more than 6,000 pounds of chicken strips due to labeling that failed to declare the product contained the known allergens wheat and soy, according to a press release.

  10. Jury now deliberating death for Arias

    Jury now deliberating death for Arias

    Jurors in the Jodi Arias murder trial have gone home for the day after deliberating Tuesday afternoon whether the convicted killer should get a life sentence or execution.