PHOENIX - Arizona's attempt to criminalize day laborers who block traffic seeking work came in for rough treatment Wednesday before a federal appeals court.
The three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco appeared skeptical of Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer's argument that the law was a legal way to remedy traffic congestion she says is caused by day laborers. A lower court judge had previously put the law on hold.
Opponents argue the law's true purpose is to crackdown on illegal immigrants. They say it violates the laborers free speech rights and filed a lawsuit to invalidate it.
On Wednesday, the three-judge panel seemed ready to side with opponents.
"Don't you have general traffic laws?" Judge Richard Tallman asked the governor's lawyer almost immediately. The same question was asked several times by Tallman and Judge Raymond Fisher throughout the hour-long hearing. The two Clinton-appointed judges wondered why a new law was needed when blocking traffic is already illegal in Arizona.
"There are indeed other statutes and ordinances," replied the lawyer, Robert Henry. "But those statutes and ordinances have obviously been insufficient to deter this specific problem."
The ban was part of Arizona's Senate Bill 1070, which included among other provisions the so-called "show me your papers" law that captured national attention.
The U.S. Supreme Court this summer upheld that provision, which requires police enforcing other laws to question the immigration status of all those they suspect are in the country illegally.
The high court struck down several portions of the immigration law, however, including sections that made it a crime for immigrants to be without federal immigration papers, mandated jail time for illegal immigrants who sought work in Arizona and made it easier for local police to make immigration-related arrests.
Still other provisions, including the day laborers section, are still being litigated.
Judge Consuelo Maria Callahan, appointed by President George W. Bush, the remaining judge on the panel considering the provision said that Arizona's position was "not unsympathetic," but that its attempts to address illegal immigration, however, are "not doing really well with the Supreme Court."
Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
RIGHT NOW on ABC15.com
Authorities searched a Tempe middle school Friday morning after receiving a report that a student had allegedly brought a gun to school, Tempe police said.
The Devils will square off against Stanford, the defending Rose Bowl champion, which won the regular season meeting 42-28 after racing out to a 29-0 halftime lead.
Check out this plush Scottsdale property sold recently for $6.1 million!
Officials are investigating after a body was found in a dumpster Friday morning in Mesa.
The White House says President Barack Obama and first lady Michelle Obama will travel to South Africa next week to pay respects to Nelson Mandela.
City officials recommend that people traveling to Tempe arrival early and use park-and-ride lots and take light rail.
Take a journey through the years to see the incredible life of former South African president Nelson Mandela, who led the struggle against apartheid in his homeland.
Defending champion Spain will play its opening World Cup game against the Netherlands, a repeat of the ill-tempered 2010 final.
A family of seven escaped a house fire early Friday morning near 16th Street and Southern Avenue in Phoenix.
Eating nutritional foods is one of the best ways to reduce obesity. But following a healthy diet isn't always easy, especially for lower socioeconomic groups.