FACT CHECK: Republican Congressional Committee attack ad on Ann Kirkpatrick

Ann_Kirkpatrick_20110330181729_JPG

Ann Kirkpatrick
Photographer: kirkpatrickforarizona.com

Advertisement

Posted: 09/17/2012

PHOENIX, AZ - The National Republican Congressional Committee is spending nearly a million dollars on airtime for an attack ad here in Arizona leading up to the November election.

Their focus is Democrat Ann Kirkpatrick , a candidate for Congress in Arizona's first district.

The ad's first claim is that Kirkpatrick helped pass 'ObamaCare'.

ABC15 determined that claim to be a FACT.

During her last term in Congress, Kirkpatrick did vote for the Affordable Care Act.

The ad next alleges Kirkpatrick's vote in favor of the Affordable Care Act could destroy 249,000 jobs.

ABC15 determined that allegation is MOSTLY FICTION.

The NRCC cites a study from the National Federation of Independent Businesses that President Obama's health care plan could cost the United States anywhere from 125,000 to 249,000 jobs.

But the independent, impartial website FactCheck.org writes "claims about the health care law killing jobs are overblown."

Factcheck.org cites the potential for job increases in the health and insurance industries which they say means the Affordable Care Act would likely only result in a "small net job loss."

The ad's final claim is that the Affordable Care Act, and Kirkpatrick's vote by extension, will raise taxes by $2,000 for some families.

ABC15 determined that claim to be MISLEADING.

It's true that some will pay more taxes because of the Affordable Care Act but the ad says those increases will impact the middle class.

According to FactCheck.org, the tax increase only kicks in for individuals who earn $200,000 or more and families earning $250,000 or more. Those salaries are not representative of people in the middle class.

The ad concludes by the narrator stating "The better choice? Jonathan Paton . Combat veteran, fiscal conservative. He'll vote to repeal Obamacare, lower taxes and help create jobs."

The Kirkpatrick campaign released a statement to ABC15 that reads:


This attack is pure nonsense. Ann Kirkpatrick has a strong record of putting our district first. In 2010, Ann was even named as one of the ‘Top 10 most rebellious members of Congress’ because of her willingness to break from her party when she believed it was right for our district. But we expect national Republicans to keep distorting Ann's record as they prop up payday-loan lobbyist Jonathan Paton.
 

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
advertisement

RIGHT NOW on ABC15.com


  1. RAW: Arias talks 1-on-1 with ABC15

    RAW: Arias talks 1-on-1 with ABC15

    Arias sat down with ABC15's Amy Murphy Tuesday night, just hours after jurors began deliberating, to speak out about the trial, her feelings about Travis Alexander's death and whether she wants to live or die.

  2. Man tries to abduct teen in Scottsdale

    Man tries to abduct teen in Scottsdale

    Police are investigating after a man tried to abduct a 19-year-old woman in Scottsdale Tuesday night.

  3. DWTS names new 'Dancing' champ

    DWTS names new 'Dancing' champ

    The winner earned two sets of perfect scores Monday night.

  4. Use it? New dangers of Mirena IUD

    Use it? New dangers of Mirena IUD

    Many women are reporting complications to the federal government regarding the Mirena IUD.

  5. Should Arias get the death penalty?

    Should Arias get the death penalty?

    A path of heartbreak, violence, lies and finally confessions has led Jodi Arias to where she is now -- at the mercy of jurors deciding whether or not she should live.

  6. FORECAST: Triple digits back soon!

    FORECAST: Triple digits back soon!

    Find out when the 100s come back and if they'll stick around through Memorial Day weekend.

  7. Arias speaks out as jury deliberates

    Arias speaks out as jury deliberates

    Jodi Arias begged jurors Tuesday to give her life in prison, saying she "lacked perspective" when she said she preferred execution to spending the rest of her days in jail. 

  8. Bisbee approves new civil unions measure

    Bisbee approves new civil unions measure

    The Bisbee City Council has approved a revised version of an ordinance that would legalize civil unions for same-sex couples.

  9. PD: 2 injured in Glendale shooting

    PD: 2 injured in Glendale shooting

    Police say two people were taken to the hospital Tuesday night after a shooting in Glendale.

  10. Anthony Weiner launches mayoral bid

    Anthony Weiner launches mayoral bid

    The ex-congressman whose career imploded in a rash of raunchy tweets two years ago said in a YouTube video announcement late Tuesday that he's in the New York City mayoral race.