FACT CHECK: Flake attack web ad on Carmona

KNXV_Jeff_Flake_Richard_Carmona_ad_20120904174246_JPG

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 09/04/2012

PHOENIX, AZ - After winning the Republican primary for United States Senate, Jeff Flake wasted little time to attack his opponent in the general election, Richard Carmona .

"We know where (Flake) stands, Richard Carmona not so clear," the narrator says in the ad.

In the ad that's currently running online only , Flake accuses Carmona of not taking a stand on key issues.

"I don't have any thoughts on that, I did not see that,  I haven't studied that specifically," Carmona is shown saying in the ad.

ABC15 determined the allegation that Carmona hasn't taken a stand on key issues is FICTION.

The ad claims Carmona dodges the issues but doesn't reference specific issues.

A simple Google search shows Carmona's stance on multiple issues.

The ad also alleges Carmona is the "hand-picked candidate" of President Obama.

ABC15 determined that claim to be a FACT.

According to a POLITICO article earlier this year , Carmona was "personally courted by President Obama."

But, as Carmona's campaign points out, Carmona was twice recruited by Republicans to run for governor and for Congress.

Lastly, the ad claims Carmona supported President Obama's Affordable Care Act .

ABC15 determined that allegation is FACT. In this YouTube clip , Carmona states that he supports the Affordable Care Act.

"Dr. Carmona believes Democrats and Republicans both got it wrong," said Andy Barr, spokesperson for the Carmona campaign, attempting to clarify Carmona's remarks.

"Dr. Carmona thinks there are problems with the Affordable Care Act’s business plan we need to fix by refocusing on preventive care and changing how we treat chronic disease in order to reduce our spiraling health costs," added Barr.

Barr released the following statement to ABC15:

Congressman Jeff Flake is a career politician and former lobbyist who knows he can't run on his record or the issues, so he chose to launch his campaign with an ugly and misleading attack. As Congressman Flake knows, Dr. Carmona was twice recruited by Republicans to run for Governor and for Congress. Congressman Flake also knows that Senators Jon Kyl and John McCain encouraged Dr. Carmona to serve as Surgeon General of the United States in a Republican administration."
"Dr. Carmona chose to launch his campaign with a positive message introducing himself to Arizona voters. Congressman Flake immediately chose to launch his race with ugly and false attacks. I think that says a lot about the choice Arizona has.

 

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
advertisement

RIGHT NOW on ABC15.com


  1. What happens if Arias jury can't decide?

    What happens if Arias jury can't decide?

    Jurors in the Jodi Arias trial have gone home Wednesday and will continue deliberations in the morning.

  2. RAW: Arias talks 1-on-1 with ABC15

    RAW: Arias talks 1-on-1 with ABC15

    Arias sat down with ABC15's Amy Murphy Tuesday night, just hours after jurors began deliberating, to speak out about the trial, her feelings about Travis Alexander's death and whether she wants to live or die.

  3. Cadillacs recalled over loose wheels

    Cadillacs recalled over loose wheels

    General Motors Co. is recalling more than 27,000 Cadillac SUVs worldwide because the wheels can fall off.

  4. Dead cell? 10 ways to boost battery life

    Dead cell? 10 ways to boost battery life

    Smartphones are an amazing bit of technology, but all those features come at a high cost: battery life.

  5. FORECAST: Hot, windy Arizona

    FORECAST: Hot, windy Arizona

    Wind Advisories and Red Flag Warnings are in place across Northern Arizona. Find out how strong winds will blow and when they'll back off.

  6. Agree? Poll: Family needs $58K/year

    Agree? Poll: Family needs $58K/year

    A recent poll showed that Americans believe it’s necessary to make more than twice the federal poverty level for a family of four to “get by” in their community.

  7. FD: 2 children critically hurt in wreck

    FD: 2 children critically hurt in wreck

    A Phoenix Fire Department spokesman says two adults were also hurt but their injuries are not serious.

  8. Should Arias get the death penalty?

    Should Arias get the death penalty?

    Jurors in the Jodi Arias murder trial went home around 4:30 p.m. Wednesday after being unable to reach a unanimous verdict on whether she should be sentenced to life in prison or death.

  9. Workers sue Goodyear Tires over crash

    Workers sue Goodyear Tires over crash

    Three state employees are suing Goodyear Tires over an April rollover accident they say was caused by a defective tire tread.

  10. Arrest made in Ash Fork teen's death

    Arrest made in Ash Fork teen's death

    Authorities in northern Arizona say a Williams man is in custody in connection with the fatal shooting of an Ash Fork teenager.