FACT CHECK: DCCC's TV ad attacking Jonathan Paton

KNXV_Johnathan_Paton_20120912172523_JPG

Johnathan Paton
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 09/12/2012

PHOENIX, AZ - Jonathan Paton's candidacy for the United States House of Representatives comes under attack in a 30-second ad by the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee that supports his opponent, Ann Kirkpatrick , in the November election.

"They call him Payday Paton," says the ad's narrator. "A corporate lobbyist who worked for the payday loan industry."

ABC15 determined that allegation is a FACT.
 
Paton did register as a lobbyist and worked the Community Financial Services Association which represents the payday loan industry.

However, Paton's spokesperson insists Paton simply ran a charity funded by the CFSA and never lobbied on any payday bill.

"(Paton) even defended their predatory targeting of seniors," the narrator says next in the ad.

ABC15 determined that claims is also a FACT.

In an article in the Tucson Citizen dated January 22nd, 2004 , the newspaper quoted Paton as saying
"What are we supposed to do, tell people: 'We can't give you a loan because you're too old?'"

"As a legislator, Paton pushed a deceptive initiative to bailout the payday industry and 'allow the continued gouging of the everyday citizen,'" says the narrator in the ad's final claim.

ABC15 determined that claim is INCONCLUSIVE.

Paton did support Prop 200 in 2008 which the payday loan industry also supported.

But a Paton spokesperson claims Paton supported it for the opposite reason the ad claims and that Paton believed it would result in tighter regulation and fewer payday lending stores in Arizona.

Paton's statement on the Arizona Secretary of State's website backs up that claim.

Paton's campaign released the following statement to ABC15:

“It’s no surprise that Ann Kirkpatrick’s Democrat allies in Washington are doing everything possible to distract from her support for the failed Obama record. This ad is a complete distortion of the facts. Jonathan is an Iraq veteran who once represented a charity that put money back into the community through scholarships to Arizona students. That’s a real contrast to Kirkpatrick’s record of rubber-stamping ObamaCare and the trillion dollar stimulus.”

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
advertisement

RIGHT NOW on ABC15.com


  1. 10PM: ABC15 goes 1-on-1 with Arias

    10PM: ABC15 goes 1-on-1 with Arias

    Jodi Arias begged jurors Tuesday to give her life in prison, saying she "lacked perspective" when she said she preferred execution to spending the rest of her days in jail. TONIGHT: Arias speaks out to ABC15.

  2. Senate panel approves immigration bill

    Senate panel approves immigration bill

    Far-reaching legislation that grants a chance at citizenship to millions of immigrants living illegally in the United States cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee on a solid bipartisan vote.

  3. Suns get 5th pick in NBA draft lottery

    Suns get 5th pick in NBA draft lottery

    The Cleveland Cavaliers got the No. 1 pick.

  4. Jury now deliberating death for Arias

    Jury now deliberating death for Arias

    Jurors in the Jodi Arias murder trial have gone home for the day after deliberating Tuesday afternoon whether the convicted killer should get a life sentence or execution.

  5. FORECAST: Triple digits back soon!

    FORECAST: Triple digits back soon!

    Find out when the 100s come back and if they'll stick around through Memorial Day weekend.

  6. Looking? 5 BEST tips for buying a car

    Looking? 5 BEST tips for buying a car

    Auto leasing expert Steven Sternberg gives his five tips for buying a car.

  7. PHOTOS: Arias slideshow during trial

    PHOTOS: Arias slideshow during trial

    Jodi Arias presented a lengthy slideshow  -- including childhood and family photos -- to the jury during Tuesday's penalty phase.

  8. VIDEO: SWAT crashes into PHX home

    VIDEO: SWAT crashes into PHX home

    Air15 video over the area showed the massive vehicle crashing through the home multiple times as armed crews stood by behind shields.

  9. BBQ for fallen PHX officer, firefighter

    BBQ for fallen PHX officer, firefighter

    A community barbecue in Phoenix this Wednesday will benefit the families of the Phoenix police officer and firefighter who died last weekend.

  10. How to help Oklahoma tornado victims

    How to help Oklahoma tornado victims

    Several groups are collecting donations for tornado victims. Some have indicated that financial donations are preferred over supplies