Yuhnke Commentary: Got a smartphone? Which case should you buy?

Smartphone Cases_20110805205745_JPG

Various Smartphone Cases
Photographer: Kirk Yuhnke
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 08/06/2011

PHOENIX - So, you've finally decided to take the plunge and drop a few hundred dollars on a brand new shiny smartphone. Now it's time to figure out a way to protect your "precious" new tech toy.  With screens made of glass and replacement prices above $400, dropping your phone and buying a new one isn’t exactly something you would want to do. So, what case do you get? I’m going to take you through some of the various options on the market.

Basic screen protection

I’ll start with the least amount of protection. The first thing many people want to do is protect their screen against scratches. Zagg  is one of my favorites for this. It's one of many companies that offer clear plastic anti-scratch film that adheres to your screen without using glue. You can remove it at anytime without leaving a film.  If you plan to do it yourself, have some patience and take your time. Attaching one of these protective coverings without getting bubbles or dirt trapped in between the film and your screen can be difficult. Personally, I leave it to the pros. Companies like Ghost Armor have kiosks at the mall where workers will sell you the film and install it for you. It will cost a bit more but from my experience these guys know exactly what they’re doing. This is basic protection but for some people who prefer to leave their smartphone “naked”, it’s a good option to protect the screen.

Bumper case

A notch above simple screen protection is the bumper case. I’ve only seen these available for the iPhone 4 because of its unique square shape but you may be able to find bumpers for your smartphone. It provides basic protection around the edges of the phone but leaves the front and back open. This is a nice option if you’re looking for some protection against drops but want to keep the main surfaces clear. With that said, it doesn’t provide much protection to either surfaces. It’s better than nothing... but barely.

Soft shell case

Next up, the soft case. I tried out one from a company called Rearth . Their case is called the Ringke . It’s made mostly of a silicone substance that can easily bend but is designed to form fit your phone. It’s very easy to pop this case on and off of your smartphone. It doesn’t add a lot of thickness or weight to your smartphone. I really like the feel of the Ringke case. Rearth says they “surface etch” the outside of the case. I don’t know what surface etching is but I like it. It doesn’t feel like cheap rubber. My only complaint is that while it provided a snug fit, it’s a bit loose around the edges.

This case is perfect for someone looking for an inexpensive custom case that provides good protection against scratches and minor drops. It’s also great for someone who plans to remove and re-attach their case on a regular basis. I’m worried that over time the case would loosen if you re-applied it often. While Rearth does sell a great kit ($20.99) that includes a screen film, a headphone plug and the Ringke case, the case alone ($16.99) does not provide any screen protection. Anyone looking to add a splash of color to their phone will love the Ringke case, it’s available in over 10 different vibrant colors.

Hard shell case

If you’re looking for something as simple as the soft case but with a touch more protection, consider a hard shell case. I tested the Feather Ultralight Hard Shell case from Incipio . It’s made of a super thin plastic that seems to weigh almost nothing. It snaps firmly onto your phone. Once in place, it’s clearly not going anywhere. Like the soft case, the Incipio case does not add much bulk or weight to the phone. The Incipio case also doesn’t wrap around the top and bottom of the phone as much as the Ringke case so you get a touch less protection there. None the less, it feels solid and does a good job without taking away from the touch and the feel of the phone itself.

The Incipio Feather Ultralight Hard Shell case is perfect for anyone who wants to buy a thin light case and leave it in place. It will also leave the face of the phone open so you will want to consider a screen protector along with the Incipio case. You’ll pay a bit more for this case, the Incipio feather Ultralight Hard Shell Case sells for $24.99 and comes in a variety of sleek colors.

Soft shell / hard shell case

Sedio takes it up one notch with a combination of both the soft case and a hard shell. It’s called the Sedio Active X. It consists of two pieces, a silicone soft case and a hard shell that clamps on top of the silicone case. It took a bit more work to get both pieces on the phone but once it was clamped in place, it felt nice and snug. As you would expect, the Sedio Active X adds more bulk than the previous two cases but also seems to provide more protection. I liked the snug fit of the Sedio although it does take away from the slim sleek feel of your smartphone. It’s time make a decision, form over function? I’ll let you decide.

The Sedio Active X case is perfect for someone

who plans to take their smartphone with them outdoors and wants to make sure it can take a few bumps along the way. The Sedio Active X sells for $29.99.

Protection and power

For the ultimate case that goes beyond just protection, check out Powerskin . It’s a silicone case and extended battery all-in-one. Slide powerskin over your phone making sure that the power plug slides into the plug on your phone. The skin will cover up your charging port but also includes a new port that can be used to charge both your phone and the extended battery. The company claims this will double the life of your phone. The case works well and is simple to use. There’s even a button on the back that will show you the current charge level of the extended battery.

It offers no protection to the front of the phone, there’s only a sliver of a “lip” to protect your phone if you place it face down on a surface. I would definaly suggest a screen protector for anyone using the Powerskin as their main smartphone case. As you can imagine, the included battery does add a significant amount of thickness and weight to the phone. I tried it on the Evo 4G which weighs 170g. The Powerskin case added an additional 77.1g. It will add bulk but so many smartphones suck through batteries in no time so it may be worth it for you. The Powerskin is priced right at only $54.99 and could prove to be a lifesaver for anyone who can’t afford to have a dead smartphone battery halfway through the day.

How do I decide?

Which case you chose is 100 percent a personal decision. It will depend on your style, your need for protection and how much additional thickness and weight you want to add to your phone. My suggestion is to stop by your favorite store and check them out for yourself. Nothing beats a hands-on demo. Most stores will let you slip a case onto your phone to check it out.

What do you use to protect your smartphone? Comment below or chime in on Facebook or Twitter .

Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
advertisement

Did You Hear?


  1. VIDEO: Wife dumps beer on husband

    VIDEO: Wife dumps beer on husband

    A man who was trying to protect his wife from a home run ball got a face full of beer for his effort.

    • Happy 140th Birthday, blue jeans

      Happy 140th Birthday, blue jeans

      Jim Heston, an American guesthouse operator in Cambodia, has lived a life in denim and has the photos to prove it. There were the dungarees he wore as a little boy, the dark bell-bottoms he had on for a hike up Japan's Mount Fuji, and the Levis straight-leg 501 jeans he's stayed with for the past 36 years.

      • 1st 'Harry Potter' book hits auction

        1st 'Harry Potter' book hits auction

        A first edition copy of "Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone" that contains author J.K. Rowling's notes and original illustrations is going on sale in a charity auction.

        • Stay Connected