Which smoke detectors warn of fires faster?

smokedetector_20101007143352_JPG

Copyright 2010 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 03/11/2013

Fire officials will tell you that many fatal fires they’ve seen involved non-working smoke detectors.

So, they advise testing your detector regularly and changing batteries routinely.

But there are so many alarms available on store shelves, which one works fastest?

Photoelectric alarms detect smoldering fires faster.

But, most homes have a different fire alarm, with ionization technology.

Those alarms quickly detect fast-flaming fires.

Our sister station in Cleveland, put alarms to the test.

Their local fire department set up ionization alarms, photoelectric alarms and dual alarms with both technologies.

Then they set a fire by placing a lit cigarette into the crack in a sofa. They waited to see when the alarms would sound.

Four minutes into this test, one of the photoelectric alarms sounded.

Less than a minute later, the other photoelectric brand went off.

Then, the dual alarms with both technologies sounded.

But the alarms used by most people, the ionization alarms, had still not sounded. 

In this test, the ionization detector sounded 9 minutes and 12 seconds after the photoelectric alarm.

In a government test, it took even longer.

Thirty minutes ticked by before the ionization alarm went off.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission and alarm manufacturers recommend having both kinds of alarms, or a dual alarm in your home.

Whichever you choose, make sure you change the batteries routinely and test them to make sure they work.

Email me with anything you want investigated or "like" my ABC 15 Facebook page and tell me about it there.

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments

Facebook Twitter Bio

advertisement

RIGHT NOW: Top Stories


  1. Jodi Arias jury back in deliberations

    Jodi Arias jury back in deliberations

    Jurors in Jodi Arias' trial resumed deliberations Thursday, a day after they reported they were unable to reach a unanimous verdict on whether she should be sentenced to life in prison or death.

    • 1 killed in MD parking garage collapse

      1 killed in MD parking garage collapse

      Fire and rescue officials say a parking garage that was closed to the public has partially collapsed outside a shopping mall in Bethesda, Md., killing one person and severely injuring another.

      • GOP Medicaid supporter gets threat

        GOP Medicaid supporter gets threat

        A visibly shaken Rep. Kate Brophy McGee said she received an obscene and threatening voicemail due to her support of Medicaid expansion.

        • NOW: Dump truck fire closes US 93

          NOW: Dump truck fire closes US 93

          The fire has closed both directions of the highway about 20 miles north of Wickenburg.

          • PD: Student hackers changed grades

            PD: Student hackers changed grades

            Three 16-year-old Prescott High School students have been arrested on suspicion of hacking into teachers’ computers and changing grades.

            • Busy 2013 hurricane season predicted

              Busy 2013 hurricane season predicted

              The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said there is a 70 percent chance that this year will be more active than an average hurricane season.